If you find yourself in Flagstaff craving something that feels equal parts comforting and elevated, Fat Olives should be at the top of your list. This neighborhood favorite delivers wood-fired Neapolitan pizza and rustic Italian dishes in a warm, welcoming space that balances casual charm with authentic flavor. Whether you’re passing through or spending the weekend in town, Fat Olives brings people together over good food and relaxed conversation.
The Story Behind the Dough
Fat Olives began over 25 years ago as a mobile catering company and has grown into one of Flagstaff’s most beloved restaurants. Founded by award-winning chef John Conley, the concept is rooted in tradition, quality, and community. John has been featured in newspapers, magazines, and national food publications for his commitment to authentic Italian cooking and locally sourced ingredients. Today, that same passion fuels every dish that comes out of the wood-fired oven.
The Menu That Keeps You Coming Back
You’re here for the pizza, no question about it. The dough is fermented for 48 hours, blistered in a 900-degree oven, and topped with simple but rich flavors like house-made mozzarella, spicy soppressata, and vibrant San Marzano tomatoes. But the menu doesn’t stop at pizza. From handmade pastas to buttery arancini to fresh caprese salads, every bite feels crafted with intention. And if you’re just in the mood for drinks and a bite, their wine list and house cocktails make it easy to settle in and stay a while. Locals love the wood-fired wings, and if you happen to visit during a seasonal special, go for it. This is a place that respects tradition but still likes to play.
Stay Close to What Matters
After your meal, there’s nothing better than heading back to a space that feels just as warm and inviting. At Porter, our Flagstaff vacation rentals give you a private home base close to local favorites like Fat Olives. Whether you’re planning a quick weekend escape or an extended stay, our homes come with plenty of perks to make your time here even better. Enjoy outdoor space, fully equipped kitchens, smart TVs, and cozy interiors designed for downtime.
Plan Your Flagstaff Getaway
If you’re thinking about heading to Fat Olives, take the time to make a whole trip of it. Book your stay with Porter and experience Flagstaff like a local!
